This wiki is obsolete, see the NorduGrid web pages for up to date information.

NOX/Tests/Security test results

From NorduGrid
Jump to navigationJump to search

ARC1 security testing

Test environment

MacOSX 10.5.8 (Leopard)

Charon

ARC Policy

INI config

profile=/Users/roczei/security/charon/CharonSecure.xml

pidfile=/tmp/arched.pid
logfile=/tmp/arched.log
debug=VERBOSE

libpath=/Users/roczei/arc1/lib/arc

port=60000

cacert=/Users/roczei/arc1/etc/certificates
host_cert=/Users/roczei/arc1/etc/cert.pem
host_key=/Users/roczei/arc1/etc/key.pem

[charon]
urlpattern=^/Charon$
policy_file=/Users/roczei/security/charon/ARC_Policy_Example.xml

XML profile

<?xml version="1.0"?>
<cfg:ArcConfig xmlns="http://www.nordugrid.org/schemas/loader/2009/08" xmlns:cfg="http://www.nordugrid.org/schemas/arcconfig/2009/08" xmlns:tcp="http://www.nordugrid.org/schemas/tcp/2009/08" xmlns:tls="http://www.nordugrid.org/schemas/tls/2009/08" xmlns:charon="http://www.nordugrid.org/schemas/charon/2009/08">
    <cfg:Server>
        <cfg:PidFile inisections="common" initag="pidfile">/tmp/arched.pid</cfg:PidFile>
        <cfg:Logger>
            <cfg:File inisections="common" initag="logfile">/var/log/arched.log</cfg:File>
            <cfg:Level inisections="common" initag="debug">ERROR</cfg:Level>
        </cfg:Logger>
    </cfg:Server>
	<ModuleManager>
        <Path inisections="common" initag="libpath">/usr/local/lib/arc/</Path>
	</ModuleManager>
	<Plugins><Name>mcctcp</Name></Plugins>
	<Plugins><Name>mcctls</Name></Plugins>
	<Plugins><Name>mcchttp</Name></Plugins>
	<Plugins><Name>mccsoap</Name></Plugins>
	<Plugins><Name>arcshc</Name></Plugins>
	<Plugins><Name>charon</Name></Plugins>
	<Chain>
		<Component name="tcp.service" id="tcp">
			<next id="tls"/>
            <tcp:Listen>
                <tcp:Interface inisections="common" initag="interface">0.0.0.0</tcp:Interface>
                <tcp:Port inisections="common" initag="port"/>
                <tcp:Version inisections="common" initag="ipversion">4</tcp:Version>
            </tcp:Listen>
		</Component>
	<Component name="tls.service" id="tls">
		<next id="http"/>
            <tls:KeyPath inisections="common" initag="host_key"/>
            <tls:CertificatePath inisections="common" initag="host_cert"/>
            <tls:CACertificatesDir inisections="common" initag="cacert"/>
	</Component>
		<Component name="http.service" id="http">
            <next id="soap">POST</next>
            <next id="plexer">GET</next>
            <next id="plexer">PUT</next>
		</Component>
		<Component name="soap.service" id="soap">
			<next id="plexer"/>
		</Component>
		<Plexer name="plexer.service" id="plexer">
            <next id="charon_service" inisections="charon" initag="urlpattern">^/Charon$</next>
		</Plexer>
		<Service name="charon" id="charon_service">
			<charon:PDPConfig>
				<charon:PolicyStore>
				<charon:Location Type="file" inisections="charon" initag="policy_file">charon_policy.xml</charon:Location>
				</charon:PolicyStore>
				<charon:Evaluator name="arc.evaluator" />
				<charon:Policy name="arc.policy" />
				<charon:Request name="arc.request" />
			</charon:PDPConfig>
		</Service>
	</Chain>
</cfg:ArcConfig>

Error: 

[2009-11-05 07:22:11] [Arc.ModuleManager] [VERBOSE] [75787/8425248] Loaded /Users/roczei/arc1/lib/arc/libsaml2sp.so
[2009-11-05 07:22:11] [Arc.ModuleManager] [VERBOSE] [75787/8425248] Loaded /Users/roczei/arc1/lib/arc/libslcs.so
[2009-11-05 07:22:11] [Arc.ArcEvaluator] [ERROR] [75787/8425248] Can not parse classname for FunctionFactory from configuration
[2009-11-05 07:22:11] [Arc.Service] [INFO] [75787/8425248] Succeeded to produce Evaluator
[2009-11-05 07:22:11] [Arc.Loader] [INFO] [75787/8425248] Loaded Service charon(charon_service)
[2009-11-05 07:22:11] [Arc.Loader] [INFO] [75787/8425248] Linking MCC tcp.service(tcp) to MCC (tls) under (empty)

XACML Policy

INI config

profile=/Users/roczei/security/charon/CharonSecure.xml

pidfile=/tmp/arched.pid
logfile=/tmp/arched.log
debug=VERBOSE

libpath=/Users/roczei/arc1/lib/arc

port=60000

cacert=/Users/roczei/arc1/etc/certificates
host_cert=/Users/roczei/arc1/etc/cert.pem
host_key=/Users/roczei/arc1/etc/key.pem

[charon]
urlpattern=^/Charon$
policy_file=/Users/roczei/security/charon/XACML_Policy_Example.xml

XML profile

<?xml version="1.0"?>
<cfg:ArcConfig xmlns="http://www.nordugrid.org/schemas/loader/2009/08" xmlns:cfg="http://www.nordugrid.org/schemas/arcconfig/2009/08" xmlns:tcp="http://www.nordugrid.org/schemas/tcp/2009/08" xmlns:tls="http://www.nordugrid.org/schemas/tls/2009/08" xmlns:charon="http://www.nordugrid.org/schemas/charon/2009/08">
    <cfg:Server>
        <cfg:PidFile inisections="common" initag="pidfile">/tmp/arched.pid</cfg:PidFile>
        <cfg:Logger>
            <cfg:File inisections="common" initag="logfile">/var/log/arched.log</cfg:File>
            <cfg:Level inisections="common" initag="debug">ERROR</cfg:Level>
        </cfg:Logger>
    </cfg:Server>
	<ModuleManager>
        <Path inisections="common" initag="libpath">/usr/local/lib/arc/</Path>
	</ModuleManager>
	<Plugins><Name>mcctcp</Name></Plugins>
	<Plugins><Name>mcctls</Name></Plugins>
	<Plugins><Name>mcchttp</Name></Plugins>
	<Plugins><Name>mccsoap</Name></Plugins>
	<Plugins><Name>arcshc</Name></Plugins>
	<Plugins><Name>charon</Name></Plugins>
	<Chain>
		<Component name="tcp.service" id="tcp">
			<next id="tls"/>
            <tcp:Listen>
                <tcp:Interface inisections="common" initag="interface">0.0.0.0</tcp:Interface>
                <tcp:Port inisections="common" initag="port"/>
                <tcp:Version inisections="common" initag="ipversion">4</tcp:Version>
            </tcp:Listen>
		</Component>
	<Component name="tls.service" id="tls">
		<next id="http"/>
            <tls:KeyPath inisections="common" initag="host_key"/>
            <tls:CertificatePath inisections="common" initag="host_cert"/>
            <tls:CACertificatesDir inisections="common" initag="cacert"/>
	</Component>
		<Component name="http.service" id="http">
            <next id="soap">POST</next>
            <next id="plexer">GET</next>
            <next id="plexer">PUT</next>
		</Component>
		<Component name="soap.service" id="soap">
			<next id="plexer"/>
		</Component>
		<Plexer name="plexer.service" id="plexer">
            <next id="charon_service" inisections="charon" initag="urlpattern">^/Charon$</next>
		</Plexer>
		<Service name="charon" id="charon_service">
			<charon:PDPConfig>
				<charon:PolicyStore>
				<charon:Location Type="file" inisections="charon" initag="policy_file">charon_policy.xml</charon:Location>
				</charon:PolicyStore>
				<charon:Evaluator name="xacml.evaluator" />
				<charon:Policy name="xacml.policy" />
				<charon:Request name="xacml.request" />
			</charon:PDPConfig>
		</Service>
	</Chain>
</cfg:ArcConfig>

Error: 

[2009-11-05 07:31:20] [Arc.ModuleManager] [VERBOSE] [75806/8425248] Loaded /Users/roczei/arc1/lib/arc/libslcs.so
[2009-11-05 07:31:20] [Arc.ArcEvaluator] [ERROR] [75806/8425248] Can not parse classname for FunctionFactory from configuration
[2009-11-05 07:31:20] [Arc.Service] [INFO] [75806/8425248] Succeeded to produce Evaluator
[2009-11-05 07:31:20] [Arc.Loader] [INFO] [75806/8425248] Loaded Service charon(charon_service)
[2009-11-05 07:31:20] [Arc.Loader] [INFO] [75806/8425248] Linking MCC tcp.service(tcp) to MCC (tls) under (empty)

Charon test results

  • The ArcEvaluator has a bug
  • Charon config is not compatiable with the new INI config system. We need to convert the Evaluator, the Policy, the Request attributes to XML elements
  • Is it possible to add comments into INI config?!

UsernameToken

New profile and files:

http://svn.nordugrid.org/trac/nordugrid/browser/arc1/trunk/src/hed/profiles/EchoServiceUsernameToken

Results

Server side

[2009-11-05 09:03:55] [Arc.MCC] [VERBOSE] [76658/8529664] No security processing/check requested for 'incoming'
[2009-11-05 09:03:55] [Arc.MCC] [VERBOSE] [76658/8529664] No security processing/check requested for 'outgoing'
[2009-11-05 09:04:07] [Arc.MCC] [VERBOSE] [76658/8531072] No security processing/check requested for 'incoming'
[2009-11-05 09:04:07] [Arc.MCC.TCP] [DEBUG] [76658/8531072] next chain element called
[2009-11-05 09:04:07] [Arc.MCC.TLS] [DEBUG] [76658/8531072] Peer name: /C=HU/O=NIIF CA/OU=GRID/OU=NIIF/CN=Gabor Roczei/emailAddress=roczei@niif.hu
[2009-11-05 09:04:07] [Arc.MCC.TLS] [DEBUG] [76658/8531072] Identity name: /C=HU/O=NIIF CA/OU=GRID/OU=NIIF/CN=Gabor Roczei/emailAddress=roczei@niif.hu
[2009-11-05 09:04:07] [Arc.MCC.TLS] [DEBUG] [76658/8531072] CA name: /C=HU/O=NIIF/OU=Certificate Authorities/CN=NIIF Root CA
[2009-11-05 09:04:07] [Arc.MCC] [VERBOSE] [76658/8531072] No security processing/check requested for 'incoming'
[2009-11-05 09:04:07] [Arc.MCC] [VERBOSE] [76658/8531072] No security processing/check requested for 'incoming'
[2009-11-05 09:04:07] [Arc.SecHandler] [INFO] [76658/8531072] Succeeded to authenticate UsernameToken
[2009-11-05 09:04:07] [Arc.MCC] [VERBOSE] [76658/8531072] Security processing/check passed
[2009-11-05 09:04:07] [Arc.Plexer] [DEBUG] [76658/8531072] Operation on path "/Echo"
[2009-11-05 09:04:07] [Arc.Service] [VERBOSE] [76658/8531072] No security processing/check requested for 'incoming'
[2009-11-05 09:04:07] [Arc.Echo] [DEBUG] [76658/8531072] process: request=<?xml version="1.0"?>
<soap-env:Envelope xmlns:echo="urn:echo" xmlns:soap-enc="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/encoding/" xmlns:soap-env="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/envelope/" xmlns:xsd="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance">
  <soap-env:Header xmlns:wsse="http://docs.oasis-open.org/wss/2004/01/oasis-200401-wss-wssecurity-secext-1.0.xsd" xmlns:wsse11="http://docs.oasis-open.org/wss/oasis-wss-wssecurity-secext-1.1.xsd" xmlns:wsu="http://docs.oasis-open.org/wss/2004/01/oasis-200401-wss-wssecurity-utility-1.0.xsd">
    <wsse:Security>
      <wsse:UsernameToken>
        <wsse:Username>oliver</wsse:Username>
        <wsse:Password Type="http://docs.oasis-open.org/wss/2004/01/oasis-200401-wss-username-token-profile-1.0#PasswordDigest">ZWvOpD4NpaSTrQhlp5kanp8Wu3Q=</wsse:Password>
        <wsse:Nonce>0oW2quUdirb9KPZe0/jrAQ==</wsse:Nonce>
        <wsu:Created>2009-11-05T08:04:07Z</wsu:Created>
      </wsse:UsernameToken>
    </wsse:Security>
  </soap-env:Header>
  <soap-env:Body>
    <echo:echo>
      <echo:say>Hello Oliver</echo:say>
    </echo:echo>
  </soap-env:Body>
</soap-env:Envelope>

[2009-11-05 09:04:07] [Arc.Echo] [DEBUG] [76658/8531072] process: response=<?xml version="1.0"?>
<soap-env:Envelope xmlns:echo="urn:echo" xmlns:soap-enc="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/encoding/" xmlns:soap-env="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/envelope/" xmlns:xsd="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance">
  <soap-env:Header/>
  <soap-env:Body>
    <echo:echoResponse>
      <echo:hear>{{Hello Oliver}}</echo:hear>
    </echo:echoResponse>
  </soap-env:Body>
</soap-env:Envelope>

[2009-11-05 09:04:07] [Arc.MCC] [VERBOSE] [76658/8531072] No security processing/check requested for 'outgoing'
[2009-11-05 09:04:07] [Arc.MCC] [VERBOSE] [76658/8531072] No security processing/check requested for 'outgoing'

Client side

[roczei@zion-2:~/security/usernametoken] $arcecho -z client.conf https://localhost:60000/Echo "Hello Oliver"
{{Hello Oliver}}
[roczei@zion-2:~/security/usernametoken] $

Conclusion

The UsernameToken security handler working perfectly.

X509Token

New profile and files:

http://svn.nordugrid.org/trac/nordugrid/browser/arc1/trunk/src/hed/profiles/EchoServiceX509Token

Results

Server side

INI config
profile=/Users/roczei/security/x509token/EchoServiceX509Token.xml

pidfile=/tmp/arched.pid
logfile=/tmp/arched.log
debug=VERBOSE

port=60000

cacert=/Users/roczei/arc1/etc/certificates
host_cert=/Users/roczei/arc1/etc/cert.pem
host_key=/Users/roczei/arc1/etc/key.pem

libpath=/Users/roczei/arc1/lib/arc

x509token_ca=/Users/roczei/security/x509token/niif_ca_root_x509.pem

[echo]
prefix={{
suffix=}}
XML profile
<?xml version="1.0"?>
<cfg:ArcConfig xmlns="http://www.nordugrid.org/schemas/loader/2009/08" xmlns:cfg="http://www.nordugrid.org/schemas/arcconfig/2009/08" xmlns:tcp="http://www.nordugrid.org/schemas/tcp/2009/08" xmlns:tls="http://www.nordugrid.org/schemas/tls/2009/08" xmlns:echo="http://www.nordugrid.org/schemas/echo/2009/08">
    <cfg:Server>
        <cfg:PidFile inisections="common" initag="pidfile">/tmp/arched.pid</cfg:PidFile>
        <cfg:Logger>
            <cfg:File inisections="common" initag="logfile">/var/log/arched.log</cfg:File>
            <cfg:Level inisections="common" initag="debug">ERROR</cfg:Level>
        </cfg:Logger>
    </cfg:Server>
    <ModuleManager>
        <Path inisections="common" initag="libpath">/usr/local/lib/arc/</Path>
    </ModuleManager>
    <Plugins>
        <Name>mcctls</Name>
        <Name>mcchttp</Name>
        <Name>mccsoap</Name>
        <Name>mcctcp</Name>
        <Name>echo</Name>
        <Name>arcshc</Name>
    </Plugins>
    <Chain>
        <Component name="tcp.service" id="tcp">
            <next id="tls"/>
            <tcp:Listen>
                <tcp:Interface inisections="common" initag="interface">0.0.0.0</tcp:Interface>
                <tcp:Port inisections="common" initag="port"/>
                <tcp:Version inisections="common" initag="ipversion">4</tcp:Version>
            </tcp:Listen>
        </Component>
        <Component name="tls.service" id="tls">
            <next id="http"/>
            <tls:KeyPath inisections="common" initag="host_key"/>
            <tls:CertificatePath inisections="common" initag="host_cert"/>
            <tls:CACertificatesDir inisections="common" initag="cacert"/>
        </Component>
        <Component name="http.service" id="http">
            <next id="soap">POST</next>
            <next id="plexer">GET</next>
            <next id="plexer">PUT</next>
        </Component>
        <Component name="soap.service" id="soap">
            <next id="plexer"/>
            <SecHandler name="x509token.handler" id="x509token" event="incoming">
                <Process>extract</Process>
                <CACertificatePath inisections="common" initag="x509token_ca">./testcacert.pem</CACertificatePath>
            </SecHandler>
        </Component>
        <Plexer name="plexer.service" id="plexer">
            <next id="echo" inisections="echo" initag="urlpattern">^/Echo$</next>
        </Plexer>
        <Service name="echo" id="echo">
            <echo:prefix inisections="echo" initag="prefix">[</echo:prefix>
            <echo:suffix inisections="echo" initag="suffix">]</echo:suffix>
        </Service>
    </Chain>
</cfg:ArcConfig>
Server log
[2009-11-05 21:21:51] [Arc.Loader] [INFO] [81779/8425264] Linking MCC http.service(http) to Plexer (plexer) under GET
[2009-11-05 21:21:51] [Arc.Loader] [INFO] [81779/8425264] Linking MCC http.service(http) to MCC (soap) under POST
[2009-11-05 21:21:51] [Arc.Loader] [INFO] [81779/8425264] Linking MCC http.service(http) to Plexer (plexer) under PUT
[2009-11-05 21:21:51] [Arc.Loader] [INFO] [81779/8425264] Linking MCC soap.service(soap) to Plexer (plexer) under (empty)
[2009-11-05 21:21:51] [Arc.Loader] [INFO] [81779/8425264] Linking Plexer plexer to Service (echo) under ^/Echo$
[2009-11-05 21:21:51] [Arc] [INFO] [81779/8425264] Service side MCCs are loaded
[2009-11-05 21:21:56] [Arc.MCC] [VERBOSE] [81779/8484944] No security processing/check requested for 'incoming'
[2009-11-05 21:21:56] [Arc.MCC.TCP] [DEBUG] [81779/8484944] next chain element called
[2009-11-05 21:21:56] [Arc.MCC.TLS] [DEBUG] [81779/8484944] Peer name: /C=HU/O=NIIF CA/OU=GRID/OU=NIIF/CN=Gabor Roczei/emailAddress=roczei@niif.hu
[2009-11-05 21:21:56] [Arc.MCC.TLS] [DEBUG] [81779/8484944] Identity name: /C=HU/O=NIIF CA/OU=GRID/OU=NIIF/CN=Gabor Roczei/emailAddress=roczei@niif.hu
[2009-11-05 21:21:56] [Arc.MCC.TLS] [DEBUG] [81779/8484944] CA name: /C=HU/O=NIIF/OU=Certificate Authorities/CN=NIIF Root CA
[2009-11-05 21:21:56] [Arc.MCC] [VERBOSE] [81779/8484944] No security processing/check requested for 'incoming'
[2009-11-05 21:21:56] [Arc.MCC] [VERBOSE] [81779/8484944] No security processing/check requested for 'incoming'
No Signature node in SOAP header
func=xmlSecDSigCtxVerify:file=xmldsig.c:line=355:obj=unknown:subj=node != NULL:error=100:assertion: 
Signature verification failed
[2009-11-05 21:21:56] [Arc.SecHandler] [ERROR] [81779/8484944] Failed to verify X509 Token inside the incoming SOAP
[2009-11-05 21:21:56] [Arc.MCC] [INFO] [81779/8484944] Security processing/check failed
[2009-11-05 21:21:56] [Arc.MCC.SOAP] [ERROR] [81779/8484944] Security check failed in SOAP MCC for incoming message
[2009-11-05 21:21:56] [Arc.MCC] [VERBOSE] [81779/8484944] No security processing/check requested for 'outgoing'
[2009-11-05 21:21:56] [Arc.MCC] [VERBOSE] [81779/8484944] No security processing/check requested for 'outgoing'
[2009-11-05 21:21:56] [Arc.MCC] [VERBOSE] [81779/8484944] No security processing/check requested for 'incoming'
[2009-11-05 21:21:56] [Arc.MCC.TCP] [DEBUG] [81779/8484944] next chain element called
[2009-11-05 21:21:56] [Arc.MCC.TLS] [DEBUG] [81779/8484944] Peer name: /C=HU/O=NIIF CA/OU=GRID/OU=NIIF/CN=Gabor Roczei/emailAddress=roczei@niif.hu
[2009-11-05 21:21:56] [Arc.MCC.TLS] [DEBUG] [81779/8484944] Identity name: /C=HU/O=NIIF CA/OU=GRID/OU=NIIF/CN=Gabor Roczei/emailAddress=roczei@niif.hu
[2009-11-05 21:21:56] [Arc.MCC.TLS] [DEBUG] [81779/8484944] CA name: /C=HU/O=NIIF/OU=Certificate Authorities/CN=NIIF Root CA
[2009-11-05 21:21:56] [Arc.MCC] [VERBOSE] [81779/8484944] No security processing/check requested for 'incoming'
[2009-11-05 21:21:56] [Arc.MCC] [VERBOSE] [81779/8484944] No security processing/check requested for 'outgoing'


Client side

Config

client.conf: 

[common]

keypath=/Users/roczei/.globus/userkey.pem
certificatepath=/Users/roczei/.globus/usercert.pem
cacertificatesdirectory=/Users/roczei/arc1/etc/certificates
overlayfile=/Users/roczei/security/x509token/x509token.xml

overlay file: 

<ArcConfig>
  <Plugins overlay="add">
    <Name>arcshc</Name>
  </Plugins>
  <Chain>
    <Component name="soap.client">
      <SecHandler name='x509token.handler' id='x509token' event='outgoing' overlay="add">
            <Process>generate</Process>
            <CertificatePath>/Users/roczei/.globus/usercert.pem</CertificatePath>
            <KeyPath>/Users/roczei/.globus/userkey.pem</KeyPath>
      </SecHandler>
    </Component>
  </Chain>
</ArcConfig>


Client log
[roczei@zion-2:~/security/x509token] $arcecho -z client.conf https://localhost:60000/Echo "Hello Oliver"
func=xmlSecTransformRsaSha1GetKlass:file=app.c:line=773:obj=unknown:subj=transformRsaSha1Id:error=9:feature is not implemented: 
func=xmlSecTmplSignatureCreate:file=templates.c:line=70:obj=unknown:subj=signMethodId != NULL:error=100:assertion: 
There is not wsu:Id attribute in soap body, add a new one
func=xmlSecTransformSha1GetKlass:file=app.c:line=934:obj=unknown:subj=transformSha1Id:error=9:feature is not implemented: 
func=xmlSecTmplSignatureAddReference:file=templates.c:line=247:obj=unknown:subj=signNode != NULL:error=100:assertion: 
func=xmlSecTmplReferenceAddTransform:file=templates.c:line=448:obj=unknown:subj=referenceNode != NULL:error=100:assertion: 
func=xmlSecTmplReferenceAddTransform:file=templates.c:line=448:obj=unknown:subj=referenceNode != NULL:error=100:assertion: 
func=xmlSecTransformSha1GetKlass:file=app.c:line=934:obj=unknown:subj=transformSha1Id:error=9:feature is not implemented: 
func=xmlSecTmplSignatureAddReference:file=templates.c:line=247:obj=unknown:subj=signNode != NULL:error=100:assertion: 
func=xmlSecTmplReferenceAddTransform:file=templates.c:line=448:obj=unknown:subj=referenceNode != NULL:error=100:assertion: 
func=xmlSecTmplReferenceAddTransform:file=templates.c:line=448:obj=unknown:subj=referenceNode != NULL:error=100:assertion: 
func=xmlSecTmplSignatureEnsureKeyInfo:file=templates.c:line=194:obj=unknown:subj=signNode != NULL:error=100:assertion: 
func=xmlSecCryptoAppKeyLoad:file=app.c:line=1259:obj=unknown:subj=cryptoAppKeyLoad:error=9:feature is not implemented: 
Can not load key

[roczei@zion-2:~/security/x509token] $

Conclusion

  • Maybe the X509Token security handler has a bug or I am doing something in wrong way

SAMLToken

Profile: http://svn.nordugrid.org/trac/nordugrid/browser/arc1/trunk/src/hed/profiles/EchoServiceSAMLToken

Conclusion

  • I have not found any solution to test it, I need Weizhong help
Retrieved from "https://wiki.nordugrid.org/w/index.php?title=NOX/Tests/Security_test_results&oldid=1948"